Part 2
Sibila woke at dawn still wearing her dress.
Her cloak covered her shoulders.
Absalom’s letter lay beneath one hand.
Hunger woke with her.
She had no food.
No bucket.
No cooking pot.
No idea where the nearest spring was.
For several minutes she sat on the edge of the carved bed and permitted herself the practical inventory the asylum had trained into her.
Nine dollars and fifteen cents remaining.
One cloak.
Two dresses.
One bad pair of shoes.
No employment.
One mountain cabin.
Seven acres.
A dead grandfather.
A secret in the walls.
It was not much of a plan.
She went outside.
Morning fog filled the valley below the ridge like white water. The mountaintops rose through it as islands. Dew soaked her skirt.
Behind the cabin, Sibila found a shallow spring flowing through a stone channel Absalom had built into the hillside. The water ran clear into a carved basin, then spilled into a wooden trough.
There was also a woodshed.
Four cords of split oak stood stacked beneath its roof.
An ax remained buried in the chopping block.
A small garden had gone mostly wild, but she found onions beneath the weeds, three sound winter squashes under dying vines, dry beans still hanging from poles, and an apple tree bent beneath neglected fruit.
The old man had left food in the ground without knowing when she would come.
Sibila was carrying apples inside when she heard a wagon.
A small gray-haired woman climbed down.
She wore a man’s work coat over a brown dress and carried a crock against her hip.
She stood looking at Sibila.
Then her eyes filled.
“Lord above,” she whispered. “Rosalyn.”
Sibila froze.
The woman corrected herself.
“No. Forgive me. You’re Sibila. Temperance Marchbanks.”
She lifted the crock.
“Chicken and dumplings.”
Sibila almost laughed from the cruelty of those words to an empty stomach.
Temperance came inside, poured coffee, and deliberately looked out the window while Sibila ate.
Only after the last dumpling was gone did she speak.
“You read his letter?”
Sibila nodded.
“And you know what he said?”
“Find the seams.”
Temperance looked around the cabin.
“He never showed me.”
“You were close to him?”
“Close enough to quarrel.”
For the first time Sibila smiled.
Temperance began to stand.
“I’ll help.”
“No.”
The word came too sharply.
Temperance stopped.
Sibila lowered her voice.
“I’m sorry. I need to do the first one myself.”
The old woman studied her.
Then she sat.
“All right.”
Sibila began at the fireplace.
Her eyes found nothing.
Her hands did.
Three summers washing linens in Marberry had taught her that fingertips could know things eyesight missed. Soap residue, scorch, rust, grease, worn cloth, hidden tears—each had its own texture.
She ran her fingers along the mortar.
At the fourth row of stones she felt a line too smooth to be natural.
She pushed.
Nothing happened.
She put her shoulder against the stone.
It shifted inward.
Temperance stood.
Sibila pushed again.
The stone slid sideways.
Behind it was a cedar-lined compartment.
Inside lay an oilcloth bundle.
Sibila unwrapped it.
A wooden hawk rested in her hands.
It was so carefully made that she could almost see breath beneath the carved feathers. Each primary feather had been separated. The feet curved around a branch textured like real bark. The grain of the wood had been selected to mimic markings across the bird’s breast.
On the underside were letters and a date.
AF 1833.
Temperance covered her mouth.
“What?”
“Your mother was born in 1833.”
Sibila looked at the hawk.
“He made it for her?”
“He made two. A matched pair. One went over Rosalyn’s cradle. Then over her bed.”
“And this one?”
“He hid it.”
“Why?”
Temperance sat heavily.
“Absalom once told me he was making things for somebody he hadn’t met yet.”
Sibila spent the day searching.
Once she understood Absalom’s seams, they appeared everywhere.
Behind a panel beside the bed she found a cherry fox with its head tilted toward an imaginary sound.
Another compartment held two rabbits.
One behind the mantel concealed a carved trout rising through wooden water.
A hidden space near the ceiling held a child’s rocking chair disassembled into seven perfectly fitted pieces.
A panel beneath the shelf contained a folding writing desk made of walnut and maple, its border formed from hundreds of tiny inlaid leaves.
Fourteen compartments.
Fourteen pieces.
The last held Absalom’s tools.
Nine chisels.
Five gouges.
A marking knife.
Dividers.
A block plane.
Each handle had been worn into the shape of a dead man’s palm.
Sibila held one chisel.
“He put his hands in here.”
Temperance understood.
“Yes.”
They carried the carvings onto the floor where afternoon sunlight touched them.
Sibila sat among them.
“If these are so good, why didn’t he sell them?”
“Wouldn’t.”
“Why?”
“He sold ordinary things. Tables. Chairs. Coffins. Cradles. But these?”
Temperance shook her head.
“Never.”
“Then what are they worth?”
“Money?”
Temperance looked almost offended.
“I couldn’t tell you.”
“Thaddius said the whole cabin was worth three dollars.”
Temperance snorted.
“Thaddius wouldn’t recognize value if it sat on his breakfast plate.”
Sibila stared at the hawk.
Temperance said quietly, “Your mother took its twin when she left.”
The world narrowed.
“She took it where?”
“East.”
“Why did she leave?”
The old woman did not answer quickly.
“Vashti.”
The name was enough.
Temperance told Sibila about Rosalyn.
How she sang while working.
How she sat on the ridge and sang to hawks.
How Absalom had adored her.
How Thaddius married Vashti Attinger, a woman who believed the Fenimore name ought to become something more important than a carpenter’s name.
At first Vashti criticized little things.
Rosalyn’s manners.
Her friends.
Her habit of talking to mill hands and wagon drivers as equals.
Then she began whispering to Absalom.
Rosalyn was reckless.
Rosalyn embarrassed the family.
Rosalyn would destroy Thaddius’s prospects.
Rosalyn should marry.
Rosalyn should leave.
“It took years,” Temperance said. “Not one great cruelty. Small ones. That’s how most homes are poisoned. Teaspoon by teaspoon.”
“What did my grandfather do?”
“Fought.”
“Did he send her away?”
Temperance looked toward the valley.
“Rosalyn came to my place one morning in 1853 carrying one bag. She said she was going east to find work.”
“Did he stop her?”
“I don’t know what happened in that kitchen.”
“But he searched?”
“Nineteen years.”
Temperance’s voice softened.
“Then he learned she’d died.”
Sibila closed her eyes.
“He rode to Marberry at eighty-two. County wouldn’t give him your address.”
“I know the law.”
“He wrote anyway.”
“How often?”
“Every month.”
Sibila looked around the cabin.
“Where are the letters?”
“He said they were here.”
That night, after Temperance left, Sibila searched again.
Near midnight she noticed a narrow shadow beneath one wall panel.
She pressed.
A hidden drawer slid forward.
Its face had no handle.
Sibila ran her fingertips beneath it.
Words had been carved where they could be felt but not easily seen.
For the one they give it to.
Her pulse quickened.
The brass cabin key had a strange narrow tip.
Until that moment she had assumed the keymaker had made a mistake.
Absalom Fenimore did not make mistakes.
Sibila lay flat on the floor and found a tiny lock beneath the drawer.
The narrow end of the key fitted.
Click.
The drawer opened.
Inside were four leather books.
And hundreds of letters.
Sibila lifted one bundle.
Then another.
Letters addressed to Rosalyn.
Letters addressed to Sibila.
Letters that had gone out and returned.
She spent hours opening them in order.
Absalom apologizing.
Absalom begging Rosalyn simply to tell him she was alive.
Absalom describing the cabin being built.
Absalom writing that the west room was made for her because she had always liked evening light.
Then Sibila noticed something wrong.
Some envelopes had postmarks.
Some did not.
She lined them across the floor.
The mailed letters were stamped by postal clerks.
The unmailed ones were clean.
Yet Absalom’s journals recorded the dates he had supposedly sent them.
October 1857.
Sent Rosalyn’s letter with Thaddius.
No postmark.
January 1858.
Thaddius promised he would see it posted in Tarnwick.
No postmark.
March 1858.
Vashti taking mail east. Gave her Rosalyn’s letter.
No postmark.
Again.
Again.
Again.
Sibila counted thirty-seven.
Thirty-seven letters Absalom believed had entered the mail.
Thirty-seven that had never been canceled by a post office.
All entrusted to Thaddius or Vashti.
She turned another page of the journal.
A loose envelope fell out.
This one was different.
It was addressed to Absalom.
The handwriting belonged to a woman.
The return address was Marberry.
Sibila’s hands trembled as she opened it.
Papa,
I have written five times.
I do not know why you refuse to answer.
If you truly wish me gone, I will stop troubling you.
I married a good man named Samuel Renshaw. He died last winter of fever. I have a daughter.
Her name is Sibila.
She has your stubborn chin.
I wish you could see her.
Rosalyn
There was no postal mark.
No opened seal from Absalom.
The envelope had never been mailed.
It had been hidden with the others.
Sibila sat utterly still.
Her grandfather had not abandoned her mother.
Her mother had not abandoned him.
Someone had stood between them.
Someone had taken two people who loved one another and made each believe the other had chosen silence.
The next morning Temperance found Sibila at the table surrounded by letters.
“What is it?”
Sibila slid Rosalyn’s letter across.
Temperance read it.
Her face changed.
“Where did you find this?”
“In his drawer.”
“He never saw it.”
“No.”
Temperance lowered herself into the chair.
“Vashti.”
“You know that?”
“I know enough to fear it.”
Sibila looked toward the road.
“I have to confront them.”
Temperance reached across and closed one weathered hand around Sibila’s wrist.
“No.”
Sibila stared.
“Why?”
“Because you have evidence of one letter and suspicion about the rest. Vashti has lived fifty-five years learning how to explain herself.”
Sibila pulled away.
“What am I supposed to do?”
“What your grandfather did.”
Temperance pointed at the cabin.
“Build carefully.”
One Comment on “Part 2”