Not in fear. In a different key, something between a sob and a name.
Inside the box, on a bed of white tissue paper, was a photograph.
A hospital photograph, the same kind as the ones I had in the box on the shelf of my closet. The same white blanket. The same sleeping face. But this photograph was different from mine in one specific way.
In this photograph, the baby’s eyes were open.
Logan was making a sound I had not heard from him since he was very small, a sound without words, and I was holding him with one arm and holding the photograph with the other hand and I was doing
something I had not done in front of him in years, which was crying without managing it.
The baby in the photograph had Logan’s nose.
And her eyes were open.
I do not know how long we stood there.
I became aware eventually of the morning continuing around us, the neighbor’s sprinkler starting its cycle, a car on the street, the ordinary ambient evidence that the world was proceeding in its normal
register while our particular morning was not.
I brought Logan inside.
I made him sit at the kitchen table, which he did, and I made coffee for myself and poured him a glass of
orange juice that he did not drink, and I put the photograph on the table between us and we looked at it together.
“She was alive,” Logan said.
“The photograph shows her with her eyes open,” I said carefully. “I don’t know what that means exactly.”
“It means she was alive,” he said.
I thought about what I knew, which was what I had been told, in a hospital room twenty-six years ago while I was weak and medicated and not fully capable of processing information. I thought about the conversations I had had since then, the grief counseling in the first year, the moments when I had asked
Dr. Anand questions and received answers that had seemed complete at the time and that I had not thought to press further because grief is not an investigative mode.
“I need to make some calls,” I said.
“Mom,” Logan said.
“I know.”
“Someone knows something,” he said. “Someone put that box there. Someone has been knowing something for fifteen years and didn’t tell us and instead cut down Lily’s garden on our birthday and left a box with a note in it.” His voice had moved from the initial shock into something with edges to it, the
particular quality of Logan working through something and arriving at something he was not going to step back from. “Who did this?”
“I don’t know yet,” I said.
“But you’re going to find out.”
“Yes,” I said. “I am going to find out.”
The first call I made was to my mother.
She answered on the second ring, which was normal for Fran before eight in the morning because my mother had been a morning person her entire life and considered it a character virtue that she had never
succeeded in transmitting to me.
I told her what had happened.
There was a silence on her end that I had not heard from her before, not in twenty-six years of difficult
conversations, a silence with a specific quality, and I understood in the middle of that silence that my
mother knew something.
“Mom,” I said.
“Grace,” she said.
“What do you know?”
Another silence.
“I need to come over,” she said.
“Come now,” I said.
She arrived in twelve minutes, which was faster than the drive from her house to mine at normal speed, which told me she had already been in her car before the call ended.
She came in the back door the way she always came in, and she looked at Logan at the kitchen table and then at the photograph and her face did the thing faces do when something long contained has reached its boundary.
She sat down.
She put her hands flat on the table.
“There is something I was told not to tell you,” she said. “That I agreed not to tell you. That I have not told you for twenty-six years. And I have to tell you now.”
Logan looked at her.
I looked at her.
“Tell me,” I said.
My mother told me.
Lily had not died in the hospital.
Lily had been placed for adoption.
She had been breathing when she was born, healthy, a strong cry, everything you want. The complication had not been medical. The complication had been Aaron.
In the hours after the delivery, while I was sedated, Aaron had spoken to the hospital social worker, and then to an administrator, and then, through a series of conversations that my mother had been present
for some portion of and had agreed to participate in because she had believed, at twenty-two years old, that she was doing the right thing, it had been arranged.
Aaron had said he could not support two children. Aaron had said that one child was already beyond what he was capable of, that he had been honest with himself about his limits and that his limits were
real. Aaron had said that the alternative, both children going into state care when he left, which he was going to do, was worse than one child being adopted by a family who was prepared and waiting.
He had found the family himself. This was the part that I had to hear twice. He had already been in contact with an adoption agency before the birth, had already identified a couple, had already prepared the legal groundwork, and the groundwork required my signature, which I could not give while sedated,
and so the signature had been obtained through means my mother described with a look of someone who has carried shame for a very long time and is now setting it down in the only way available, which is by speaking.
My signature had been forged.
Aaron had left.
My mother had told herself, and had kept telling herself for twenty-six years, that Lily was with a good family, that she was loved, that the alternative would have been worse, that I had been in no condition to
make this decision and someone had made it for me in the way they believed was best.
She had kept telling herself this while Logan planted lilies.
She had kept telling herself this on every birthday while Logan chose one flower and put it on an empty grave.
The grave was empty.
I sat with this for a long time.
I did not say anything to my mother. I did not trust what I would say.
Logan, who had been listening to all of it without moving, said: “Lily is alive.”
“I believe so,” my mother said. “I believe she was alive when she was placed. I don’t know where she is now.”
“Who put the box there?” Logan said.
My mother shook her head. “I don’t know. I don’t know who knows this story besides me and Aaron and the people who were at the hospital that day.”
“Aaron knows where she is?”
One Comment on “Part 4”